The Economic Times daily newspaper is available online now.

    Illinois removed a dam from Blackberry Creek in 2013; fish began spawning within two weeks, and the former impoundment’s recorded species count rose from 8 to 25

    Synopsis

    In 2013, the dismantling of the Blackberry Creek dam sparked a significant ecological shift, enabling fish to migrate freely for the first time in 180 years. Following this, the diversity of fish species surged from 8 to an impressive 25. While some species returned quickly, others were still missing post-survey.

    Image 2026-11-16 at 17

    An AI-generated image of an excavator dismantling an obsolete low-head dam on the left, and the restored stream providing habitat for native freshwater fish on the right. Image credits: ChatGPT


    Some of nature’s most remarkable success stories begin with removal. In 2013, once the dam on Blackberry Creek (Yorkville) was removed, the fish were quick to return. Shorthead redhorse and quillback began their spawning migration just under two weeks after the dam’s removal, according to Tristan Widloe and Stephen Pescitelli, biologists from the Illinois Department of Natural Resources.

    This marked the first migration seen in the creek for approximately 180 years. The creek’s natural “highway” had been closed for close to two hundred years, and the first travelers through it weren’t tourists, but fish. It’s a beautiful success story and an easy one to share online, but there is more beneath the surface. Here’s what the data from the state actually shows.

    One small wall, a very long detour


    The dam belonged to the Yorkville-Bristol Sanitary District and divided the creek from the Fox River, preventing any fish from reaching their 32-mile spawning and rearing grounds, per the Illinois Department of Natural Resources publication on dam safety. Due to the rapid degradation of the abutment, which also housed a county road, the dam was quickly removed. Firstly, a two-foot notch was cut into the dam to reduce the height of the impoundment; the dam was then fully removed and the channel restored.

    The numbers behind the comeback

    Once removed, species richness in the former impoundment rose from eight different species of fish to 25, a net gain of 17 species within that stretch of water. The catch rate increased dramatically from 74 to 1,967. Most of this increase came from species already present elsewhere in Blackberry Creek, above or below the old dam, that could now move freely into the former pool, rather than species that were entirely new to the creek system. When comparing Blackberry Creek to five other undammed creeks, it was identified that Blackberry Creek itself was missing nine species of fish that were present in the other creeks. Once the dam was removed, seven of those nine species were identified in the creek for the first time, including quillback, rosyface shiner, banded darter, and rainbow darter.

    What the headline numbers leave out

    Whilst it is lovely to hear good news, there is some more detail in this data. The evaluation of Blackberry Creek took place over three years. One fish survey was conducted before the dam was removed, and three after. Whilst this gives us an insight, we can see that not all of the nine species were present after the removal. Southern redbelly dace and black redhorse were not identified in the post-removal surveys.

    Image 2026-11-16 at 17

    A shorthead redhorse. Image credits: Wikimedia Commons

    Overall, the data shows that removal can lead to rapid success but relies upon having a nearby source of fish to recolonise the area. However, anglers should be aware that fishing directly below the dam may become less productive after removal due to fish no longer being stuck there, according to the DNR.

    Removal isn’t a one-size-fits-all fix

    An agricultural stream in Wisconsin was studied following the removal of a small old mill dam. According to Kornis et al., in their 2014 USGS report titled “Fish community dynamics following dam removal in a fragmented agricultural stream,” published in the journal Aquatic Sciences, two species, white sucker and yellow perch, had previously been excluded from the stream and rapidly increased to form large populations upstream. Total fish biomass doubled; however, the density of native upstream fishes decreased.

    Image 2026-11-16 at 17

    A quillback. Image credits: Wikimedia Commons


    The authors noted that removal can cause unintentional and potentially undesired species dispersal within highly fragmented networks. Knowing how key fish disperse in the target stream and surrounding waters can help predict outcomes. Many old dams exist in fragmented agricultural streams and are likely to be removed; therefore, these issues will be encountered again.

    The takeaway

    Blackberry Creek demonstrates what can happen when barriers are removed and there is a source of fish to return. Depending on the downstream environment, surrounding waters, and species present at the barrier, other streams may follow the same trend, though, as the Wisconsin stream shows, results aren’t always this clean. Blackberry Creek is a case where removal alone did most of the work, but the data suggests there is still more to understand about why some dam removals play out so differently from others.

    Add ET Logo as a Reliable and Trusted News Source

    (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel)

    (Catch all the US News, UK News, Canada News, International Breaking News Events, and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)

    Download The Economic Times News App to get Daily International News Updates.

    ...more

    (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel)

    (Catch all the US News, UK News, Canada News, International Breaking News Events, and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)

    Download The Economic Times News App to get Daily International News Updates.

    ...more

    Explore More Stories

    The Economic Times

    Stories you might be interested in