The Economic Times daily newspaper is available online now.

    The real test of investment protection is what happens after an election

    Synopsis

    Andhra Pradesh is planning to introduce an Investment Protection Act during the upcoming assembly winter session. This legislation aims to make commitments on land, approvals, and incentives binding on future governments. Such measures seek to bolster investor confidence, particularly for long-term projects. Historical instances of policy renegotiation in the state have affected this trust. Establishing transparent processes for these commitments will be crucial as states compete for investment.

    ET Bureau

    The real test of investment protection is what happens after an election

    Anil Padmanabhan

    Anil Padmanabhan

    Last week, N Chandrababu Naidu told ET that his government would introduce an Investment Protection Act in the winter session of Andhra Pradesh assembly. The proposed law would make commitments on land allotments, incentives, permissions and approvals binding on future governments, irrespective of a regime change.

    On the face of it, this is a sensible idea. Investments aren't planned around tenure of government. Commercial risks are substantial enough, particularly for long-gestation projects like semiconductor plants and infrastructure projects, which can take 20-30 yrs to yield returns.

    Given Andhra's history, such an assurance is welcome. Naidu's predecessor, Y S Jagan Mohan Reddy, sought to renegotiate solar power tariffs and agreements, a move that Andhra Pradesh High Court quashed in 2022. That episode, like India's experience with retrospective taxation - eventually rolled back after Supreme Court ruled against it - continues to cast a shadow over investor confidence.


    pic3ET Bureau

    Bridging Transitions

    Naidu's proposed legislation raises a larger question about sanctity of government policy commitments. At a time when trust in the political compact between governments and voters is under strain, the challenge is to make state assurances credible without allowing the law to lock in bad policy or shield governments from accountability.

    This isn't the first attempt by a state to ring-fence policy commitments. In 1995, Gujarat signed a loan agreement with ADB to fund politically sensitive structural reforms, including fiscal guard rails, restructuring of state PSUs and a greater role for the private sector. It was the first such loan negotiated directly with a state, although GoI was also party to the agreement, given the sovereign nature of external aid. This came soon after BJP formed its first-ever majority government in Gujarat.

    But ADB wanted assurances that a change of government would not derail the loan programme. What followed was unprecedented: Congress and BJP, sworn political rivals who had alternated in power in Gujarat, jointly pledged not to disrupt the reform agenda, even if power changed hands.

    The agreement lent unprecedented credibility to Gujarat's policy commitments. More importantly, political consensus on economic reform provided an institutional anchor. Neither ADB nor private investors exploring new opportunities had to fear policy reversals with a change of government. Results were significant. Alongside other policy initiatives, this continuity helped Gujarat emerge as a major beneficiary of India's post-2000 growth acceleration.

    Three decades later, Andhra is seeking to address the credibility deficit through a different route, at a time when states are competing fiercely to woo domestic and foreign investors. In this race, policy continuity is itself an economic asset. With political consensus increasingly difficult to forge in today's binary discourse, the state is seeking to secure policy continuity through legislation. The longer the investment cycle, the more valuable such a safeguard becomes.

    pic4ET Bureau

    Building Beyond Governments

    But such legislation must also guard against misuse. While legitimate investment decisions need protection against political flip-flops, there must also be safeguards against improper commitments. The law shouldn't make contracts immune from scrutiny in cases of fraud, corruption, non-performance or harm to public interest.

    In other words, credible commitment cannot mean an irreversible one. The answer lies in establishing transparent processes for framing investment incentives and rules in the first place.

    This matters as India enters a phase of intensifying competition among states for investment. The deciding factor may not be sweeteners on offer but whether rules will hold after an election. What investors need is not just credible commitment but credible accountability.

    The writer is an independent journalist

    Add ET Logo as a Reliable and Trusted News Source
    (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.)

    (Catch all the Business News, Breaking News, and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)

    Subscribe to The Economic Times Prime and read the ET ePaper online.

    ...more
    The Economic Times

    Stories you might be interested in