The Economic Times daily newspaper is available online now.

    Bumrah's New Zealand challenge puts India's pace-bowling choices under the scanner

    Synopsis

    Bumrah leads India's fast-bowling attack, with challenges awaiting in New Zealand's unique conditions. India has historically struggled in New Zealand, winning only five out of twenty-five Tests there. Selector decisions on pace attack are crucial, especially with multiple options available. The need for a reliable bowling unit is heightened by India's World Test Championship standing. Ultimately, cohesive planning and strategy will be key to achieving success.

    PTI

    Bumrah leads India's fast-bowling attack, with challenges awaiting in New Zealand's unique conditions.

    Anand Vasu

    Anand Vasu

    He is former joint editor-in-chief, Wisden India

    Do you want the good news first or the bad?

    A 2013 study published in the Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin found that more than 75% of people preferred to hear the tougher news first and end on a high. But, paradoxically, bearers of the same information were inclined to open with the good.

    And so, here it is: Jasprit Bumrah averages more than 30 per Test wicket in only one country — New Zealand. In his only previous visit, he picked up six wickets from two outings in 2019-20.


    New Zealand conditions are famously kind to non-spinners. Where else could Chris Harris or Gavin Larsen, with their dibbly-dobbly bag of tricks, survive, let alone thrive? The pitches are usually well grassed — as much as 15mm on the pitch at the Basin Reserve this time around, if reports are to be believed. The sea is never far away, and the weather can turn at a moment’s notice.

    India’s greatest fast bowler — and the gap between Bumrah and, say, Kapil Dev is no different from the one separating Don Bradman and Australia’s next-best batsman — averages 31.66 in these conditions. To add to the complexity, he is the only certainty, even with India choosing to play four fast-bowling options.

    Bumrah did not bowl badly in those two Tests on the last tour; in fact, there were passages of play when he was indecipherable, which suggests his returns have to be better this time.

    The good thing about him is that he does not just rock up and mechanically do his job, despite all the obvious skills at his disposal. Bumrah is thoughtful, well-prepared and never short on effort.

    Bumrah leads the attack, not purely through ability, although that would be plenty, but by setting the tone for others to follow. But because he’s so unique, it’s a fool’s errand to try and replicate his methods. The smart approach is to understand why he does what he does, and not get in the way, even if you can’t support him.

    This comes with experience, which makes it baffling that the 48-Test Mohammed Siraj isn’t a shoo-in to share the new ball. He was indeed undercooked in India’s two most recent Tests, in Sri Lanka, but placing more store in immediacy over a significant body of work is fraught with risk, aside from being borderline disrespectful to Siraj.

    Prasidh Krishna is tall, hits the deck hard, has a natural inswinger to right-hand batsmen, and has added a ball that leaves them, dabbles with the wobble seam, and good control over cutters. Prasidh has 32 wickets at 30.34 from nine Tests in a career marred by injury. But these numbers are not all down to him. Captains have used him as a short-ball machine in spells, but he is no Neil Wagner.

    If India were to be conservative — and this is in no way defensive or negative in this instance — they would do well to stick to these three as the core of the attack for the first Test, and play around only with the fourth slot.

    There’s solid logic for that place to go to any of Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj, Nitish Reddy or Gurnoor Brar, probably in that order.

    But, the desperation to win both Tests — created by India’s position in the World Test Championship table thanks to home discomfort — might well lead them down the seductive path of thinking that not gambling is as good as not trying.

    Indian teams, especially under Gautam Gambhir, have been adventurous in picking horses for courses, although this seems to apply to bowlers all the time and batsmen almost never. There has also been a tendency to take a decision and retrofit the logic behind it based on how it pans out.

    In New Zealand, India have struggled for results, despite becoming significantly better and winning consistently in England, Australia and South Africa, all of whom have been stronger than the Kiwis on paper. In 58 years, India have won only five of 25 Tests in New Zealand, and one in the last 15, stretching back to 1990.

    When Shubman Gill and Gambhir make the final call, they should spend much more energy on the core three quicks they want, because inevitably one of four will be under-bowled.

    The good news is that Gill and Gambhir have the widest choice of fast-bowling options of any Indian side to tour New Zealand, but the bad news is that they may not have 100% conviction on which four are most likely to deliver the right result.

    Add ET Logo as a Reliable and Trusted News Source
    (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.)

    (Catch all the Business News, Breaking News, and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)

    Subscribe to The Economic Times Prime and read the ET ePaper online.

    ...more
    The Economic Times

    Stories you might be interested in