The Economic Times daily newspaper is available online now.

    Shareholder suits keep firms honest

    Synopsis

    Intel is facing a class-action lawsuit initiated by shareholders who argue that the company's delay in financial disclosures has adversely affected its stock value. Recently, Intel's shares plummeted following disappointing revenue forecasts.

    1
    Intel faces a proposed class-action lawsuit filed last week by shareholders led by a pension fund, alleging the chipmaker was slow to disclose how weak PC sales would affect its revenue. The company's stock fell 29% a day after the company projected lower quarterly revenue and profit, and forecast a prolonged slowdown in PC sales. An unprecedented memory crunch has affected the PC market, and Intel, like other technology companies, is finding it difficult to capitalise on surging demand for data centre chips because of supply disruptions. The suit attempts to raise the bar for disclosure about an evolving business situation.

    Class action by shareholders is a lengthy and expensive mechanism to improve corporate governance. Cases drag on for years and payouts to individual shareholders are small. Yet, it serves as an external check on management, and the threat of collective litigation improves financial disclosure, audit integrity and transparent communication. Not just a company's directors but its auditors and consultants are held accountable. It works as an off-equilibrium threat regarding contingencies that are never met if a company's management operates within a pre-determined set of governance rules. For such a threat to work, it must be credible. The threshold for minority shareholders to initiate a class-action suit and the litigation timeframe should be reasonable.

    A cross-section of large US tech companies, including Nvidia, Apple, Alphabet and Meta, have faced shareholder class action. In contrast, India, with similar provisions, has seen a solitary case being admitted against Jindal Poly Films. Shareholder class action was introduced in the 2013 amendment of the Companies Act, but filings were non-existent for a decade. This has to do with rigidities in the provision, like meeting a minimum requirement of total shareholding, exclusion of stakeholders like bond and debenture holders, and leaving out banks from certain damage claims. This limits shareholder class actions' ability to drive structural board reforms in India.

    Add ET Logo as a Reliable and Trusted News Source

    (Catch all the Business News, Breaking News, and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)

    Subscribe to The Economic Times Prime and read the ET ePaper online.

    ...more
    The Economic Times

    Stories you might be interested in