
Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) guidelines issued in March this year allow government departments to classify their systems by risk before choosing where to host data. These rules could be modified for setting clear, mandatory directions for hosting government data, officials said.
The guidelines allow less critical, public-facing data such as details of welfare beneficiaries, public grievance logs and data on government events to be hosted on any MeitY-empanelled cloud service provider (CSP). It covers all applications and data disclosable under the Right to Information Act, 2005 and subject to the provisions of the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023.
“There are obvious risks such as leakage and disruption when it comes to such vast quantities of data, much of which may not be anonymised, personal data,” an official said. “There have been inter-ministerial discussions to outline a larger policy on cloud sovereignty. The existing categories for classifying data are large and may be further detailed,” the official said, emphasising there is currently a need to clearly specify where departments can host their data.
Under the ministry’s MeghRaj (GI Cloud) initiative, a cloud empanelment scheme officially certifies and validates both local and global CSPs. It allows government entities to securely procure virtual compute space, storage, databases, and other infrastructure services on a pay-per-use, on-demand basis.
MeitY’s current list of 30 empanelled CSPs features domestic data centre providers such as Yotta, CtrlS and Sify, as well as telecom operators such as Jio Platforms and Airtel’s Nxtra Data. Global hyperscalers including Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud, Microsoft Azure, IBM India and Oracle also feature in the list.
The existing rules leave room for treating similar types of data differently across ministries and states, resulting in varied requirements for vendors, said Harsh Walia, partner at law firm Khaitan & Co, pointing to the need for clear, mandatory classification criteria. “This matters more as the DPDP framework takes effect. Departments, other than any instrumentalities exempted, will be accountable as data fiduciaries for the safeguards over personal data hosted on any cloud.”
Defining sovereign cloud
The Centre also has a separate critical data category where any unauthorised disclosure or disruption could seriously harm national security or national interest or disrupt government operations. MeitY cited Aadhaar, UPI, PAN, passport, tax, and e-courts as such instances alongside state-level land records and treasuries.
Such workloads may be hosted only with government and specified public sector providers, as well as with sovereign cloud providers “as and when notified by MeitY”. However, the ministry is yet to decide the selection criteria for the same.
Officials said while efforts are on to choose sovereign CSPs, the process has got complicated due to global hyperscalers commanding the vast majority of the Indian cloud services market.
“All industry stakeholders are being consulted,” a second official said. “We have to ensure that any new framework promotes truly sovereign capabilities.”
The current rules should extend to procurement, with departments verifying where data is stored and processed, who can access it, how foreign legal requests are handled, and whether critical services can be restored or migrated without prolonged disruption, said Amit Singh, partner at Deloitte. “A blanket exclusion of global providers could limit technological choice and increase concentration risks,” he said. “The priority should be verifiable control over data, infrastructure, operations and continuity, with provider eligibility determined by workload requirements and demonstrated safeguards.”
The move to exercise more control over data storage is part of a larger government push towards sovereignty. Under the National Information Security Policy and Guidelines, workloads classified as ‘top secret’ and ‘secret’ aren’t permitted on clouds, while entirely government-owned and operated data operations are mandated for high security applications such as defence and core intelligence.
However, plans are afoot to identify critical sectors and data categories where technology infrastructure including graphics processing units will be completely ‘on-premises, entirely owned by the government and air-gapped,’ ET reported last month. Meanwhile, not-so-sensitive yet relatively important categories will be managed through a new framework in which the government may own the hardware such as GPUs, while private sector firms may run and operate it, officials said earlier.




